Poll: Majority of French, Danish & Dutch Positive about Muslims; Most Germans Negative

02 December 2010

Germans are more critical of Islam and less tolerant of building mosques than their neighbours in France, Denmark, the Netherlands and Portugal, a new survey has found.

Despite the often fractious relationships other European countries have with their Muslim communities, people in those countries were relatively positive about Islam and its followers compared to Germany, according to the survey commissioned by a research group based at the University of Münster (pictured).

This is surprizing, because besides Germany, each of the countries polled has had high-profile conflict with their Muslim communities – such as the cartoons in Denmark, head scarf controversies in France and the murder of anti-Islam filmmaker Theo van Gogh in the Netherlands, as well as the rise of far-right politician Geert Wilders.

Nevertheless, a clear majority of people in those countries have a positive view of Muslims. 62 per cent of Dutch, 56 per cent of French, 55 per cent of Danes and 47 per cent of Portuguese hold positive attitudes on Muslims.

By contrast, just 34 percent of western Germans and 26 percent of eastern Germans are positive about Muslims.

According to weekly Die Zeit, which reported on an advance version of the study on Thursday, four out of 10 Germans in the former West Germany and 50 percent in the former East Germany feel threatened by foreign cultures.

"Compared with the French, Dutch and Danish, a rigid and intolerant grasp of foreign religions predominates in Germany," said the head of the project, sociologist Detlef Pollack. "The statement that Islam is part of Germany is completely disregarded in the opinions of Germans."

The polling firm TNS Emnid, on behalf of the Münster researchers, surveyed 1,000 people each in the former west and former east Germany, France, Denmark, the Netherlands and Portugal. The study will be officially released later on Thursday in Berlin.

Fewer than 5 percent of Germans, compared with more than 20 percent of Danes, French and Dutch consider Islam to be a tolerant religion, according to the study.

When asked what they associated with Islam, more than 80 percent of german respondents said discrimination of women, 60 percent said fanaticism, and only eight percent of West Germans and five percent of East Germans said that Islam was peaceful.

Most Germans saw barely any positive side to Islam, Pollack said. Less than 30 percent in the former west supported the building of mosques, while in the former east the figure was less than 20 percent. The acceptance of minarets or the adoption of Muslim holidays received even less support.

In Denmark, by comparison, more than half of respondents supported the building of mosques, while in France and the Netherlands the figure was about two-thirds and in Portugal it was nearly three quarters.

The study also revealed a more prevalent anti-Jewish undercurrent in Germany than in other western European countries. The same was the case for other religions, such as Hinduism and Buddhism.

Sources:

"Germans less tolerant of Islam than neighbours, study finds" The Local - Germany December 2, 2010

"Survey shows Germans negative about Muslims and Jews" Deutsche Welle December 2, 2010

Kirsten Grieshaber, "Poll: Germans less tolerant of Muslims than other Europeans" The Canadian Press December 2, 2010