• Alukah English HomepageSitemapRSS
  • Alukah English Homepage
  • Alukah Guestbook
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Make us your Homepage
  • Contact Us
Alukah in Arabic
Alukah is a rich, cultural website supervised by Dr. Khaled El-Jeraissy and Dr. Saad El-Hmed
 
Website of Dr. Sadd Bin Abdullah El-Hmed  Supervised By 
  • Homepage
  • Islamic Shariah
  • Thoughts and Knowledge
  • Society and Reform
  • Counsels
  • Muslims around the World
  • Library
 All Sections | Jeraissiyah Library  Audio   Video   Books  
  •  
    Funeral Prayer Its Excellence and Legislated Invocations ...
    allajnat aleilmiat bialqism alnisayiyi bioumi aljud
  •  
    30 Hadiths for Children (PDF)
    Harun Alhasan
  •  
    I gained Islam as a religion without losing faith in Jesus ...
    Muhammad al-Sayed Muhammad
  •  
    Why Believe in the Almighty Creator's Absolute Power (PDF)
    Muhammad al-Sayed Muhammad
  •  
    Why Believe in the Prophet of Islam Muhammed? (PDF)
    Muhammad al-Sayed Muhammad
  •  
    Why Choose Islam as a Religion? Choosing between Islam and ...
    Muhammad al-Sayed Muhammad
  •  
    Medical Engineering
    Salem Abdullah Mohammed Lasloom
  •  
    Sustainable tourism (PDF)
    Prof . Zaid Mohammed Al-Rommany
  •  
    A Quiet dialogue Between a Christian and a Muslim (PDF)
    Muhammad al-Sayed Muhammad
  •  
    how do we protect our youth from atheism
    Samah Elshenawy
  •  
    The Kind Treatment (PDF)
    Fu’ad Bin Abdul Aziz Ash-Shalhub
  •  
    extravagance and waste: Concept - Causes - Models - Effects ...
    Prof . Zaid Mohammed Al-Rommany
Home / Thoughts and Knowledge / Thoughts

A doubt: Resorting to righteous people for intercession is not part of polytheism

Dr. Ali ibn `Abdul-`Aziz Ash-Shibl

Published On: 22/8/2015 A.D. - 7/11/1436 H.   Visited: 9788 times     


Print Friendly Version Send to your friend 



Full Text Increase Font SizeReset Font SizeDecrease Font Size
Share it
Question

What do you say about asking a live righteous person to intercede on the Day of Resurrection, such as saying: O Sheikh, intercede for me on the Day of Resurrection; is it part of polytheism?

What do you say about asking a live righteous person to intercede on the Day of Resurrection, such as saying: O Sheikh, intercede for me on the Day of Resurrection; is it part of polytheism?

Answer

This is forbidden, why? Because I do not know whether he is righteous or not and whether he will be of them or not.

 

This is forbidden as it is a means to polytheism, but you may say to the righteous person: Invoke Allah for me. This is permissible even if it is reprehensible at some scholars as it is reliance on righteous people instead of righteous deeds. It also affects the perfection of your monotheism, but it is permissible in general since it is meant for benefitting a person as the Prophet (peace be upon him) said to `Umar: "Do not forget us from your invocations, brother."[1] Did the Prophet (peace be upon him) need the invocations of `Umar (may Allah be pleased with him)?

 

The answer is: Never, but that was for `Umar to benefit from his invocation to the Prophet (peace be upon him) while he is not present, so Allah would assign two angels to say: Amen, and the same to you.[2] This meaning is explained by Sheikh-ul-Islam ibn Taymiyah and other scholars, which is good.He (may Allah bestow mercy on him) said: "When a person says: I do not associate others with Allah in worship, and resorting to righteous people for intercession is not part of polytheism. Say to him: If you admit that Allah prohibited polytheism more than the prohibition of adultery, and you admit that Allah does not forgive it, so what is that thing which Allah has prohibited and does not forgive it? If he does not know, say to him: How come you free yourself of polytheism while you do not know it? How does Allah prohibit that and mention that He shall not forgive it while you do not ask about it or even know it? Do you think that Allah would forbid something without explaining it to us?"

 

Al Maqasid As-Samiyat fi Kash Ash-Shubuhat.



[1] Reported by Abu Dawud and At-Tirmidhy 3 /356 who ranked it as good, see Mishkat Al Masabih of At-Tibrizy and the book of Ad-Da`wat 3 /191.

[2] Reported by Imam Muslim in his Sahih, and see the explanation of An-Nawawy on Sahih Muslim, the book of Dhikr, seeking forgiveness, invocation, and repentance, chapter on the virtue of invoking Allah for Muslims while they are not present No. (6864).



Print Friendly Version Send to your friend 



Selected From Alukah.net

  • Freeing oneself from polytheism and its people(Article - Islamic Shariah)
  • Beauty is part of the retribution of righteous deeds(Article - Thoughts and Knowledge)
  • I doubt my husband(Counsel - Counsels)
  • Asking people for money when one is not in need(Article - Counsels)
  • Asking people for money when one is not in need(Article - Counsels)
  • I hate the people and I do not wish goodness for anyone(Counsel - Counsels)
  • Issues about the first negator of Islam (1)
    Polytheism in worshipping Allah
    (Article - Islamic Shariah)
  • Polytheism and its types(Article - Islamic Shariah)
  • The Righteous Parents(Article - Society and Reform)
  • Days of Virtue and Righteous Deeds(Article - Islamic Shariah)

 


Our Authors
  • Those who disobey God and follow their sinful lusts..
  • One can attain real happiness
  • Islam clearly reveals to us more details about the one true ...
  • Allah the one true God is Creator, not created
  • Allah is only one, he has no children, partners or equals
  • Allah is eternal, he does not die or change
  • Islam leads to ultimate truth and success
  • Try to find out the truth abut Islam
Participate
Contribute
Spread the word
Tell a friend
All Rights Reserved © 1447H / 2026 to Alukah.Net
Site was last updated on : 15/12/1447H - at: 12:33